Files
rfc-app/backend/app/rfc_links.py
Ben Stull 3c9109c392 v0.29.0: #28 Parts 2+3 — create-RFC offers + contribute-to-pending requests
Extends the v0.26.0 (#28 Part 1) read-time scanner into three buckets in
one pass — active link (Part 1), pending-RFC contribute offer (Part 3),
create-RFC offer (Part 2) — precedence active > pending > candidate. The
backend still emits only structured segments (never HTML), so the surface
stays XSS-safe by construction.

Part 2 — create-RFC offers: a multi-word tag from the #27 taxonomy with no
defining RFC renders, for a create-rights viewer, as an inline "+ create
RFC" affordance that opens the propose modal pre-filled (?propose=<term>;
ProposeModal gained initialTitle). Conservative multi-word gate; broader
heuristics + the Haiku path are deferred.

Part 3 — contribute-to-pending offers: a term matching a super-draft
renders, for a signed-in non-owner, an "ask to contribute" affordance with
the owner's display name. It opens a 3-field request form (who/why/optional
use-case); submitting lands a contribution_requests row (migration 024) and
one actionable §15 notification per owner (new kind
contribution_request_on_pending_rfc, personal-direct). The owner's inbox
shows who/why/use-case inline with Accept/Decline. Accept fires #12's
owner-invite flow with the requester as invitee and echoes a notification
back; decline notifies the requester. Pre-merge idea PRs are out of scope.

New endpoints: GET /api/rfcs/{slug}/contribution-target,
POST /api/rfcs/{slug}/contribution-requests,
.../{id}/accept, .../{id}/decline. The invite issue path was refactored
into one reusable api_invitations.issue_invitation(...) chokepoint shared
by the manual invite endpoint and Part 3's accept.

Tests: 9 new (3 scanner-bucket unit + 6 e2e). Full suite 374 passing.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-28 20:10:13 -07:00

334 lines
13 KiB
Python
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
"""Roadmap #28 — scan submitted prose for RFC-shaped references.
The scanner splits a plain-text PR description / comment body into a list
of *segments* the frontend renders: plain-text runs interleaved with
typed link segments. The backend never emits HTML — the frontend maps
each segment onto a React node — so the surface is XSS-safe by
construction and independent of any HTML-sanitization layer.
Three buckets, one scan (Parts 13):
* ``{"type": "rfc", ...}`` — Part 1. The term matches an
**accepted** (``state='active'``) RFC; renders as a link to it.
* ``{"type": "rfc-pending", ...}`` — Part 3. The term matches a
**pending** RFC — a super-draft (``state='super-draft'``: accepted
as an idea but not yet graduated to an active RFC) — which has an
owner and a contribution surface. Renders as an "ask to contribute"
affordance carrying the owner's display name.
* ``{"type": "rfc-candidate", ...}`` — Part 2. The term is a
strong-candidate that does **not** yet have a defining RFC. Renders
(for a viewer with create rights) as a "create RFC for '<term>'"
affordance that pre-fills the propose flow.
Precedence at any position is active > pending > candidate, then
longest-match-first — an active link always wins over a contribute offer
which always wins over a create offer for the same span.
**Read-time enrichment, not submit-time persistence** (unchanged from
Part 1): drafts are never scanned, only submitted content on the read
paths, so links/offers track the *live* corpus. The active-RFC corpus,
super-draft corpus, and tag taxonomy are all small and cache-resident,
so building the index and scanning a ≤20k-char body per read is cheap.
**Matching stays conservative by design.** A reference links/offers only
when it is unlikely to be coincidental:
* ``rfc_id`` tokens (e.g. ``RFC-0001``) — inherently specific.
* Multi-word titles (containing whitespace, e.g. ``Open Human Model``).
* Hyphenated slugs (containing ``-``, e.g. ``open-human-model``).
Single common-word titles/slugs are deliberately NOT matched — they
would turn every prose occurrence into an affordance.
**Part 2 candidate heuristic.** A candidate term is a **multi-word tag**
from the #27 tag taxonomy (the de-facto set of tags the corpus already
carries) that has no defining RFC (no active or super-draft RFC whose
slug or title is that term). Multi-word is the same false-positive guard
the title rule uses: a single common tag word (``identity``) would be
far too noisy. Broader candidate detection — capitalized multi-word
phrases mined from the text, terms repeated across recently-touched PRs,
or the #27 Haiku (``ANTHROPIC_API_KEY``) pathway — is a sanctioned but
deferred extension; the conservative tag-taxonomy heuristic is chosen
here to match Part 1's false-positive-averse philosophy.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import json
import re
from typing import Any, Iterable, NamedTuple
class Term(NamedTuple):
"""One match key plus what to emit when it hits.
``key`` is the lowercase span to match (word-boundary, longest-first).
``kind`` is ``'active' | 'pending' | 'candidate'`` and selects the
emitted segment shape. ``slug``/``title`` carry the target RFC (active
+ pending); ``owner`` is the pending RFC's owner display name;
``term`` is the candidate's canonical display spelling.
"""
key: str
kind: str = "active"
slug: str = ""
title: str = ""
owner: str = ""
term: str = ""
# Lower number = higher precedence when two keys of equal length match at
# the same position. A real link beats a contribute offer beats a create
# offer.
_KIND_PRIORITY = {"active": 0, "pending": 1, "candidate": 2}
def _coerce(t: Term | tuple) -> Term:
"""Accept the legacy ``(key, slug, title)`` 3-tuple (treated as an
active term) alongside :class:`Term`, so direct unit-test callers and
older call sites keep working."""
if isinstance(t, Term):
return t
key, slug, title = t # legacy active 3-tuple
return Term(key=key, kind="active", slug=slug, title=title)
def _is_word_char(c: str) -> bool:
"""Word-boundary test. Hyphen and underscore count as word chars so a
match can't begin or end in the middle of a kebab/snake token."""
return c.isalnum() or c in ("-", "_")
def _emit(term: Term, label: str) -> dict[str, Any]:
"""The segment dict for a matched ``term``; ``label`` preserves source
casing."""
if term.kind == "pending":
return {
"type": "rfc-pending",
"slug": term.slug,
"label": label,
"title": term.title,
"owner": term.owner,
}
if term.kind == "candidate":
return {"type": "rfc-candidate", "label": label, "term": term.term}
return {"type": "rfc", "slug": term.slug, "label": label, "title": term.title}
def segment_text(text: str | None, terms: Iterable[Term | tuple]) -> list[dict[str, Any]]:
"""Split ``text`` into text / link segments against ``terms``.
``terms`` are :class:`Term` objects (or legacy ``(key, slug, title)``
active 3-tuples). Matching is case-insensitive, respects word
boundaries on both ends, and prefers the longest key — then higher
:data:`_KIND_PRIORITY` — at any position.
Always returns at least one segment; for empty/None input that is a
single empty text segment, so callers can render uniformly.
"""
ordered = sorted(
(_coerce(t) for t in terms),
key=lambda t: (-len(t.key), _KIND_PRIORITY.get(t.kind, 9)),
)
if not text:
return [{"type": "text", "text": text or ""}]
out: list[dict[str, Any]] = []
buf: list[str] = []
low = text.lower()
n = len(text)
i = 0
while i < n:
match: tuple[Term, int] | None = None
for term in ordered:
klen = len(term.key)
if klen == 0 or not low.startswith(term.key, i):
continue
before = text[i - 1] if i > 0 else ""
after = text[i + klen] if i + klen < n else ""
if _is_word_char(before) or _is_word_char(after):
continue
match = (term, klen)
break
if match is not None:
term, klen = match
if buf:
out.append({"type": "text", "text": "".join(buf)})
buf = []
out.append(_emit(term, text[i:i + klen]))
i += klen
else:
buf.append(text[i])
i += 1
if buf:
out.append({"type": "text", "text": "".join(buf)})
return out
def _keys_for(slug: str, title: str, rfc_id: str | None) -> Iterable[str]:
"""The match keys an RFC contributes. See the module docstring for why
each gate exists (conservative, false-positive-averse)."""
if rfc_id:
rid = rfc_id.strip()
if len(rid) >= 2:
yield rid.lower()
if title:
t = title.strip()
# Multi-word titles only — a single common word is too noisy.
if len(t) >= 2 and (" " in t or "\t" in t):
yield t.lower()
if slug:
s = slug.strip()
# Hyphenated slugs only — a single-token slug is a bare word.
if len(s) >= 2 and "-" in s:
yield s.lower()
def _slugify(term: str) -> str:
"""Deterministic kebab-case — mirrors the propose modal's slugify so a
tag's would-be slug compares correctly against existing RFC slugs."""
return re.sub(r"-+$", "", re.sub(r"^-+", "", re.sub(r"[^a-z0-9]+", "-", term.lower().strip())))
class LinkIndex:
"""A reusable term index built once per request and applied to many
bodies (a PR's description plus every comment on it)."""
def __init__(self, terms: Iterable[Term | tuple]):
# Coerce + order once; segment_text re-sorts defensively but a
# pre-sorted list keeps the per-body cost to the scan itself.
self._terms: list[Term] = sorted(
(_coerce(t) for t in terms),
key=lambda t: (-len(t.key), _KIND_PRIORITY.get(t.kind, 9)),
)
def __bool__(self) -> bool:
return bool(self._terms)
def segment(self, text: str | None) -> list[dict[str, Any]]:
return segment_text(text, self._terms)
def _owner_display(conn, owners_json: str | None, proposed_by: str | None) -> str:
"""The display name to show for a pending RFC's owner. First entry of
``owners_json`` resolved to its user row's display name, falling back
to the bare login, then ``proposed_by``, then a neutral noun."""
login = None
try:
owners = json.loads(owners_json or "[]")
if isinstance(owners, list):
login = next((o for o in owners if isinstance(o, str) and o.strip()), None)
except (ValueError, TypeError):
login = None
if login:
row = conn.execute(
"SELECT display_name FROM users WHERE gitea_login = ?", (login,)
).fetchone()
if row and row["display_name"]:
return row["display_name"]
return login
return (proposed_by or "").strip() or "the proposer"
def _tag_universe(conn) -> list[str]:
"""Distinct tags across the cached corpus (the #27 de-facto taxonomy),
preserving original spelling; case-deduped."""
rows = conn.execute("SELECT tags_json FROM cached_rfcs").fetchall()
out: list[str] = []
seen: set[str] = set()
for r in rows:
try:
tags = json.loads(r["tags_json"] or "[]")
except (ValueError, TypeError):
continue
if not isinstance(tags, list):
continue
for t in tags:
if not isinstance(t, str):
continue
tag = t.strip()
low = tag.lower()
if tag and low not in seen:
seen.add(low)
out.append(tag)
return out
def build_index(
conn,
*,
exclude_slug: str | None = None,
include_pending: bool = True,
include_candidates: bool = True,
) -> LinkIndex:
"""Build a :class:`LinkIndex` over the three buckets.
``exclude_slug`` drops the RFC the surrounding surface is itself scoped
to, so an RFC's own title/id/slug don't self-link (or self-offer)
inside its own PR or discussion. Precedence is enforced by insertion
order — active keys are added first and a later bucket never overrides
an already-claimed key.
"""
terms: list[Term] = []
seen: set[str] = set()
def add(key: str, term: Term) -> None:
if key in seen:
return
seen.add(key)
terms.append(term)
# --- Part 1: accepted (active) RFCs. ORDER BY slug makes key
# de-duplication deterministic when two RFCs would contribute the
# same key (first slug wins). ---
active_rows = conn.execute(
"SELECT slug, title, rfc_id FROM cached_rfcs WHERE state = 'active' ORDER BY slug"
).fetchall()
# Track every slug + title that *has* a defining RFC, so Part 2 never
# offers to create one that already exists (active or pending).
defined_slugs: set[str] = set()
defined_titles: set[str] = set()
for r in active_rows:
slug = r["slug"]
defined_slugs.add((slug or "").lower())
defined_titles.add((r["title"] or "").strip().lower())
if exclude_slug is not None and slug == exclude_slug:
continue
title = r["title"] or ""
rfc_id = r["rfc_id"] if "rfc_id" in r.keys() else None
for key in _keys_for(slug, title, rfc_id):
add(key, Term(key=key, kind="active", slug=slug, title=title))
# --- Part 3: pending (super-draft) RFCs. ---
pending_rows = conn.execute(
"""
SELECT slug, title, rfc_id, owners_json, proposed_by
FROM cached_rfcs WHERE state = 'super-draft' ORDER BY slug
"""
).fetchall()
for r in pending_rows:
slug = r["slug"]
defined_slugs.add((slug or "").lower())
defined_titles.add((r["title"] or "").strip().lower())
if not include_pending:
continue
if exclude_slug is not None and slug == exclude_slug:
continue
title = r["title"] or ""
rfc_id = r["rfc_id"] if "rfc_id" in r.keys() else None
owner = _owner_display(conn, r["owners_json"], r["proposed_by"])
for key in _keys_for(slug, title, rfc_id):
add(key, Term(key=key, kind="pending", slug=slug, title=title, owner=owner))
# --- Part 2: strong-candidate terms with no defining RFC. ---
if include_candidates:
for tag in _tag_universe(conn):
low = tag.lower()
# Conservative: multi-word tags only (same guard as titles).
if " " not in tag and "\t" not in tag:
continue
if low in defined_titles or low in defined_slugs or _slugify(tag) in defined_slugs:
continue
add(low, Term(key=low, kind="candidate", term=tag))
return LinkIndex(terms)